A Tale of Two FLIRs

USSOCOM's Combatant Craft Medium Mk.1 (CCM) at speed. CCFLIR2โ€™s turret goes on the circular pedestal behind the pilothouseโ€™s three rooftop cabin windows. Photo: USSOCOM.
USSOCOM's Combatant Craft Medium Mk.1 (CCM) at speed. CCFLIR2โ€™s turret goes on the circular pedestal behind the pilothouseโ€™s three rooftop cabin windows. Photo: USSOCOM.
USSOCOM PEO Maritime Boats Upgrading from a Legacy FLIR to CCFLIR2 really is a โ€œBig Dealโ€
Share
In the quest for โ€œWe own the night,โ€ FLIR Generations do matter. SOCOMโ€™s CCFLIR2 for its NAVSPECWARCOMโ€™s Special Boat Service Combat Craft vessels will give crews an enhanced capability that they never had.

Enter the USSOCOM CCFLIR2

In the September 2015 statement by FLIRยฎ Inc.:

The CCFLIR2 is a day/night and infrared imaging system that provides operators the capability to detect visible light or infrared radiation reflected or emitted by surface targets at tactically significant ranges in all operational environments. CCFLIR2 provides increased detection, recognition and identification ranges in all conditions; constant interrogation of targets across the spectrum of operations; and greater situational awareness with high-definition imaging and zoom capability. CCFLIR2 incorporates improved optics and image processing that allows the user to see the same target in multiple wavelengths, highlighting the target features and discriminators. CCFLIR2 integrates with embedded navigational systems and other shipboard systems to provide target and way-point geolocation and tracking functionality. CCFLIR2 is part of a collection of intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance systems available for use on Special Operations Force maritime craft.

At Virtual SOFIC 2020 in mid-May, USSOCOM PEO Maritime officials revealed that all special operations Combat Craft Boats will receive the CCFLIR2 360-degree rotating turret to replace the 2000-era FLIR Legacy systems. This USSOCOM $49,900,000 2015 contract requests all 58 CCFLIR2 systems to be delivered and installed by 2022, seven years after initial contract award. Would the CCFLIR2 be outdated in year 2022 due to progressive advancements in microchip, camera, resolution, and software technology? An analysis of FLIR progression provides revealing answers.

The photo of the CCFLIR2 turret being installed on all U.S. Special Operations Command Naval Special Warfare Command (NAVSPECWARCOM)โ€™s boats was made available in an Unclassified Powerpoint slide approved for Public Release.

Forward Looking Infra-Red (FLIR) is essentially a thermal imager sensor that measures the
ambient temperatures of objects and landscapes and creates a digital image video, enhanced with black, white, and a rainbow of colors for day/night navigation, target identification, heat source measurements, ranging, and tracking. FLIR thermal imagery allows people to see through darkness, solar flare, smoke, light fog, adverse weather, obscurants, and sandstorms where nighttime image light enhancement (i.e.: night-vision goggles) cannot do.

When it comes to being the elite of the elite in the world of clandestine special operations,
having improved FLIR camera performance through generational upgrade versions do make a
difference for improved special forcesโ€™ Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance (ISR).

Today, FLIR isnโ€™t that rare

When it comes to FLIR technology, numbers do matter. People usually wonโ€™t mistake the performance of an Appleยฎ iPhone 11 with an iPhone 8 or even an iPhone 4. The number itself represents the generation of the make and model of the iPhone and the number shouldnโ€™t get confused. Usually, the higher the model number, the newer the make and version which equates to better performance and vastly improved processing power due to Mooreโ€™s Law of miniaturization. Mooreโ€™s Law states that that the number of transistors etched on a microchip doubles every two years, thus doubling the processing speed and capability power every two years for a lower price.

FLIR thermal technology, once considered rare and very expensive and exclusively for Law Enforcement, governments and military usage, is now affordable and could be purchased commercially for hunting, maritime, civilian and recreational use.

FLIR2 and FLIR3

Respectively, FLIR2 and FLIR3 have vastly improved performance over FLIR Generation One and public online sources do state that FLIR2 handheld cameras is very similar in performance and specifications to FLIR3 handheld cameras. FLIR3 handheld cameras by FLIRยฎ has the added benefit of:

  • WiFi image transfer, in this case allowing Operators to view thermal images (securely via military communications encryption) on their military smartphones and tablets.
  • FLIR3 also has a hot/cold spot temperature indicator for identification of the hottest or coldest spot in the image.Picture-in-Picture mode.
  • Picture-in-Picture mode is helpful for overlaying the color thermal image over the daytime camera image as a hot/cold comparison reference.

FLIRยฎ Multi-Spectral Dynamic Imaging (MSX)ยฎ

FLIR3 with MSXยฎ (Multi-Spectral Dynamic Imaging) does have the added benefit of using MSX to โ€œdraw inโ€ visible light details into the thermal image (merging of visible light with the thermal image) for more detail and refinement so that the thermal image isnโ€™t represented by just shapes and shades of color. Essentially, FLIR3 with MSX outlines and borders in hard edges and surfaces for greater clarity and that is very useful for identifying manmade objects in a featureless ocean at night. But FLIR2 handheld cameras can also contain MSX Technology and thus can be very compatible in performance to FLIR3 handheld cameras. Compared to FLIR1, FLIR2 and FLIR3 with MSX Technology give special forcesโ€™ Operators an enhanced edge in combat with object and target identification.

FLIR2 and FLIR3 with MSX Technologyโ„ข merges thermal and visual imagery simultaneously. FLIR images.
FLIR2 without MSX (left) and FLIR3 with MSX (right) show how the MSX software borders and outlines for better shape definition. FLIR images.
FLIR2 without MSX rendering (left) and FLIR3 with MSX rendering (right). FLIR images.

As to which FLIR technology the NAVSPECWARCOM boats have is unknown, but FLIRยฎ Technologies confirmed over the phone that the MSXยฎ Technology is hardware, not software related, and is not downloadable to cameras or systems that do not contain the MSX Technology. FLIRยฎ Systems told Naval News that its handheld cameras do contain MSX Technology but could not confirm that the Maritime cameras contained MSX Technology. FLIRยฎ Systems declined to comment on the CCFLIR2.

Enhancing the Thermal Imagery with Improving Technology

In addition to MSX Technology, if made available on CCFLIR2, the higher and sharper the resolution of the camera, the better the image quality and detail identification and discrimination. Low and High-Definition camera resolution comparison images are provided by FLIRยฎ Marineโ€™s website.

High-Definition thermal camera shows the edges, shapes, and details of the boat (SOCOMโ€™s CCFLIR2 has HD) but without MSX Technologyโ€™sยฎ visual merging, edge bordering and outlining. FLIR image.
Low-Definition camera only shows the temperature ranges of the boat (e.g. Legacy FLIR). FLIR image.

[SOCOMโ€™s] CCFLIR2 incorporates improved optics and image processing that allows the user to see the same target in multiple wavelengths, highlighting the target features and discriminators.


FLIRยฎ, Inc. 2015

According the FLIRโ€™s 2015 statement, if CCFLIR2 does indeed highlight the features and discriminators (FLIR2 handheld cameras with MSX Technology were indeed available in 2015), then CCFLIR2 could indeed have a form of MSX Technology that merges and overlays visual with thermal images for the Maritime environment that would offer even better visual quality than a typical HD thermal camera. CCFLIR2 could use FLIR3โ€™s handheld camera features in 2015 and be ahead of its time (before FLIR3 was made) for enhanced Special Boat Serviceโ€™s survivability, sustainability, navigation, and Command, Control, Communications, Computers, Surveillance, Intelligence, and Reconnaissance (C4SIR).

In 2020, FLIRยฎ Systems currently makes HD Maritime turrets that have better designs and performance specifications than FLIRยฎ 2015โ€™s CCFLIR2. With Mooreโ€™s Law, the hardware processing power, the zoom power, the sensitivity, and the lens apertures would all be improved with progressive technological advancements over the five years. USSOCOMโ€™s CCFLIR2, even five years old, would be a marked improvement over 2000-era Legacy FLIR systems because CCFLIR2 is High-Definition (HD) quality, respectively, and MSXยฎ visual/thermal image merging and edge tracing was indeed available in 2015. This isnโ€™t to say that U.S. NAVSPECWARCOMโ€™s CCFLIR2 would be technologically outdated by 2022; however, as technology progresses, USSOCOMโ€™s Combat Craft vessels might still get new FLIR camera hardware and software upgrades well into the 2020s and for the service life of these special operationsโ€™ boats. Therefore, while not the best Marine thermal imager FLIRยฎ Systems sells in 2020, CCFLIR2 should be โ€œdecent enoughโ€ for NAVSPECWARCOMโ€™s Special Boat Teams throughout the 2020s to follow the motto, โ€œWe own the night.โ€

SeaFLIR 280-HD (example) has larger lenses, head, and one more sensor than CCFLIR2 and could be an installation option for USSOCOM boats in the future. FLIR photo.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement